How to Check an AI Explanation Against a Diagram

Title card for checking an AI explanation by comparing its claims with a source diagram.

Break the explanation into claims you can check one at a time. For a claim about an arrow, find its label, starting point, and destination in the source. If the explanation also says how much, how often, or what caused a change, look for that evidence before copying the claim into your notes.

Check two statements against the source

Open the USGS and FAO water cycle diagram. Look for the RUNOFF label by the slide near the lake, then the INFILTRATION label below and to the left. Consider this two-sentence example from a hypothetical AI tool. “The runoff arrow shows water entering the ground. All water that infiltrates reaches groundwater.”

Statement to check What you can see in the diagram Result
The runoff arrow shows water entering the ground. The path near the slide goes over the surface toward the lake. The infiltration arrows point into the ground. The answer used the wrong path.
All water that infiltrates reaches groundwater. The diagram shows PLANT UPTAKE from the soil alongside RECHARGE and the separate GROUNDWATER STORAGE and GROUNDWATER FLOW labels. Contradicted. Some infiltrating water remains in the soil, where plants take it up.

A corrected note would say, “The runoff path shown leads over the land toward the lake. Infiltration occurs where water enters the ground. Some of that water recharges groundwater. Some stays in the soil, where plants take it up.” For a text check on those processes, see the USGS explanation of surface runoff.

Start with a label and follow its marks

Find the relevant panel, and check whether the labels name processes, things, or units. Begin at the tail of the arrow and follow it to its head. Use the caption or legend to see what that type of arrow means in the diagram. A word printed near an arrow can belong to a different path.

Separate a wrong claim from a missing detail

If the source shows the arrow going to a different place, rewrite the statement using the visible endpoints. If it leaves out a quantity your explanation added, record the narrower claim the source supports. When the label is unreadable, look for the original figure or its caption before settling on an interpretation.

Check one arrow in a course diagram

Take one sentence an AI tool wrote about a figure in your notes. Write the label and endpoints that support it, then revise the sentence to match what you can verify.

🚀 Join our affiliate program and earn 25% referral commission! 🚀 Earn 25% referral commission!